Position Document: Tina

Name: Tina
Role: Parent in a Blended Family and Co-Negotiator of Holiday Schedules
Background: I share parenting responsibilities in a blended family with children from previous marriages and maintain significant relationships with extended family members across different cities.

---

Situation Overview

Every holiday season presents a multifaceted negotiation. The challenge is to balance quality time with both my children and my extended family, all while ensuring fairness with Marcus’s children. The travel demands, varied family traditions, and logistical burdens have consistently led to high stress and unresolved conflicts. My objective is to create a schedule that honors everyone’s traditions and minimizes travel-related stresses in a way that is equitable and respects the interests of each party.

Priorities and Values

First and foremost, fairness is paramount—I want to ensure that all children, regardless of which parent they call home, receive equal quality time during the holidays. Maintaining cherished family traditions is equally important, as they contribute to a sense of belonging and continuity for all involved. Additionally, I value simplicity in logistics to reduce travel fatigue, particularly given that my extended family is based in a distant city. In the context of prevailing industry best practices (which stress the importance of work/family balance) and the local cost-of-living challenges associated with long commutes or flights, it is critical that any holiday plan accounts for realistic travel times and expenses. My desire is to create a plan that does not require drastic reallocation of time or excessive travel burdens on either side.

Trade-offs and Flexibility

I am open to innovative scheduling arrangements that might involve alternating holiday weeks, splitting days for different family visits, or even coordinating certain festivities on neutral ground. While maintaining equal time for the children is crucial, I am willing to accept minor deviations if compensatory measures (such as extra weekend time) are arranged to offset imbalances. I also remain flexible regarding adjustments as long as the overall fairness and logistical feasibility are maintained. For example, I could consider a rotating visitation schedule if it ultimately reduces travel strain.

Constraints and Concerns

The key constraints include rigid work schedules during the holiday season, limited vacation budgets which necessitate mindful travel planning, and the potential emotional strain on children adjusting to multiple environments. In addition, distance is a significant factor: extended family in a different city means that repeated long journeys can become taxing and expensive over time. Lastly, ensuring that each household’s established traditions and expectations are respected is a non-negotiable requirement.

BATNA (Best Alternative to Negotiated Agreement)

1. I could propose an entirely separate schedule where the children celebrate major holidays at alternate homes on different years.
2. Organizing local mini-celebrations at each household while using technology (e.g., video calls) to connect with the other family as a backup plan.
3. Arranging for professional mediation or a holiday planning consultant if our bilateral negotiations stall significantly.

Vision of Success

A successful agreement would give each child ample, quality time with both parents and extended family without causing undue travel stress or logistical chaos. It would integrate cherished traditions with practical scheduling, ensuring that holiday celebrations are balanced, fair, and emotionally supportive. This outcome would reduce stress, strengthen family bonds, and set a replicable framework for future holiday seasons.